The Human Cost of Bill 21: What Lies Ahead as the Supreme Court Prepares to Rule?

Samer Majzoub – Montreal

When the Supreme Court of Canada releases its decision on Quebec’s secularism law on Friday morning, November 27, the focus will naturally be on constitutional questions, the notwithstanding clause, and the limits of government authority. Yet behind these legal arguments lies a human reality that should not be overlooked: the lives of men and women whose careers, opportunities, and futures have been directly affected by Bill 21. Subsequent legislation and measures have, in many ways, relied on the precedent established by the adoption of Bill 21 itself.

When it was adopted in 2019, Quebec’s secularism law was presented as a measure to reinforce state neutrality and the principle of secularism. These are legitimate democratic objectives. Quebec, like every other Canadian province, has its own history, identity, language, and distinct characteristics. The importance of preserving the neutrality of public institutions can be understated.

But the question that remains is this: Does maintaining state neutrality require restricting the personal freedoms of individuals working within public institutions?

Since Bill 21 came into force, citizens who wear what are commonly referred to as religious symbols have faced restrictions preventing them from holding certain public-sector positions, including in education and other roles involving the exercise of authority. For many, the consequences of the law are not abstract constitutional debates, but matters of employment, career aspirations, and being forced to choose between a professional path and deeply held convictions. Muslim women who wear the hijab have been among those most affected, facing barriers to entering professions for which they are fully qualified.

A teacher wearing a hijab, a Sikh citizen wearing a turban, a Jewish person wearing a kippah, or an individual wearing a cross does not compromise the neutrality of the institution in which they work. State neutrality and an individual’s freedom to express themselves through their choice of attire are not necessarily incompatible.

The impact of the law extends beyond those directly affected. When young girls see women denied professional opportunities because of what some perceive as their religious appearance, questions arise about equality, fairness, and their place in society. Inclusion should not remain merely a declared principle; it must be reflected in the opportunities available to everyone. Moreover, public discourse increasingly appears to tolerate discrimination based on culture, ethnicity, and faith. Even the targeting of women and girls has seemingly become less taboo in societies that claim to uphold freedom and equality, as though such practices become acceptable when directed at “the other.”

Debates surrounding Quebec’s particular approach to secularism have continued to intensify under the Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) and the Parti Québécois (PQ) governments. Additional restrictions have been implemented or proposed, potentially extending to other public institutions and raising questions about students’ freedom of expression as well. Regardless of which political party advances these measures, the discussion should consider not only the objectives being pursued, but also who bears their consequences and whether those consequences are proportionate to the stated goals.

The Supreme Court’s ruling will address issues that go beyond the direct restrictions imposed by Bill 21. At the heart of the case lies Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, known as the notwithstanding clause, which the Quebec government invoked when adopting the law. The Court is being asked to examine the scope of this constitutional power, the role of judicial review when governments invoke it pre-emptively, and questions concerning the educational rights of the English-speaking minority.

The case could lead to several possible outcomes. The Court may largely uphold the existing legal framework, leaving Bill 21 and its restrictions in place. It could issue a more focused ruling addressing certain constitutional questions, potentially affecting the law’s application to English-language school boards or clarifying the scope of constitutional protections for certain rights. It may also consider whether courts can issue declaratory judgments affirming that legislation violates Charter-protected rights, even when the notwithstanding clause prevents that legislation from being invalidated on those grounds. Such a ruling would not necessarily overturn Bill 21, but it could have important implications for constitutional accountability and how governments invoke Section 33 in the future.

Whatever the outcome, this ruling is likely to influence the debate over the use of the notwithstanding clause, not only in Quebec but across Canada.

For those who have paid the price of Bill 21, its consequences are direct and personal: professional barriers, difficult choices, and the feeling that full participation in public life may be conditional upon giving up part of one’s personal identity. These challenges are compounded by campaigns of hatred, hostility, and discrimination directed at them. Such concerns deserve to be heard and taken seriously, given their potential consequences for social harmony, regardless of the Court’s decision.

Quebec, like every province in Canada, has every right to preserve its language, culture, identity, and democratic institutions. But these objectives and individual freedoms should not be treated as opposing or mutually exclusive. A society can affirm its identity while ensuring that citizens of different faiths and backgrounds have equal opportunities to contribute to its future.

The Supreme Court’s ruling will mark an important moment in this ongoing debate, but the responsibility to build a society grounded in equality, dignity, and social cohesion extends beyond the courtroom and beyond any particular government.

Ultimately, a society’s strength is measured not only by the values it seeks to preserve, but also by how fairly those values are applied to everyone. Quebec and Canada must ensure that secularism, equality, and freedom can coexist without requiring some citizens to pay the price for belonging to the very society of which they are an integral part.

*Arabic version published by Sada Online : https://www.sadaonline.ca/ar/News/content/89f14912-77d3-40ce-8e7c-d44dcf76874c


Discover more from samermajzoub

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply